-
- Posted
By: Sampon <Tatsinoue@aol.com>
- Date:
Sunday, 18 August 2002, at 11:29 a.m.
-
- In
1996, I went to Mesa, AZ to see N1K2-J George at Champlin Fighter Museum.
At the Museum's parking lot, I found relics of three or four Ki-43 Oscars.
I am trying hard to recall my fading memory, and I believe that under the
Do-Not-Touch sign board, there was an explanation that the Ki-43s are
recovered from an Island of Shimushu, Kril Islands and are under
restoration. An intensive battle was fought on Shimushu between Japan and
Russia after announcement of Japan's surrender.
-
- If
there is anyone who knows what happened to the restoration project and
whereabout of these Ki-43s, please let me know. I post a photo of one of
these Ki-43s I took in December 1996. Some other photos I posted on my
album page (in Japanese), which you can enlarge by clicking them.
-
- Editors
note: Picture at http://image3.photohighway.co.jp/se-bin/MyPhoto.dll?Vi?
-
- Editors
note: Link to http://www.photohighway.co.jp/AlbumPage.asp?key=906944&un=152008&m=2&s=0
-
- Re:
Champlin's Ki-43s
-
- Posted
By: Jim Broshot <jbroshot@fidnet.com>
- Date:
Sunday, 18 August 2002, at 4:37 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Champlin's Ki-43s *PIC* (Sampon)
-
- When
I was in Oregon in May 2002, I managed to get to the Tillamook Naval Air
Station Musuem. They had a display which claimed that one of these
aircraft were to be placed on display there after the restoration was
complete.
-
- Re:
Champlin's Ki-43s
-
- Posted
By: Sampon <Tatsinoue@aol.com>
- Date:
Sunday, 18 August 2002, at 5:44 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Champlin's Ki-43s (Jim Broshot)
-
- Thanks
Nick, for a pleasant comment! And to you Jim, for precious information!
-
- I
visited the Tillamook Air Museum's page at following URL.
- http://www.tillamookair.com/aircraftlist.html
- Ki-43
Oscar was indeed in the collection list! I wonder if the restoration is
complete by now, or the plane still looks pretty much as relic. Does
anyone know? Well, probably it's best to ask the museum.
-
- Re:
Champlin's Ki-43s
-
- Posted
By: Jim Broshot <jbroshot@fidnet.com>
- Date:
Sunday, 18 August 2002, at 6:46 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Champlin's Ki-43s (Sampon)
-
- Alas,
back home in Missouri and don't know when next I will get to Oregon.
-
- FWIW
Tillamook also has, among other aircraft, a Lockheed PV-2, a Martin Mauler
and an A-24 (painted up as a SBD).
-
-
- Posted
By: James F. Lansdale <LRAJIM@aol.com>
- Date:
Thursday, 15 August 2002, at 6:06 a.m.
-
- Don
THORPE used art work by Minoru AKIMOTO as the inspiration for his
illustration on p.137, "JAAF Camouflage and Markings: WW II."
Minoru AKIMOTO is the dean of Japanese experts on this subject and he
based his art work on Japanese veterans' recollections. While the markings
of the No.20 Hiko Sentai (on his art work below) may be subject to some
revision, statements made to AKIMOTO-san regarding the blue being used as
an Oscar color are not. Most, if not all these men AKIMOTO san interviewed
are now gone!
-
- Editors
note: Picture at http://www.j-aircraft.com/jiml/ki-43_akimoto_blueoscar.jpg
-
- While
the AKIMOTO-san 1965 art may be controversial, contemporary wartime
intelligence reports are less so. Lawrence J. HICKEY ("Warpath Across
the Pacific") has a vast wealth of Allied intelligence documents
which precisely describe the colors of Japanese aircraft. One of these
documents,
-
- Intelligence
Summary No. 218, Headquarters, Allied Air Forces, SWPA 21 June, 1944,
Section IV: "TECHNICAL INTELLIGENCE"
-
- contains
information regarding IJA aircraft camouflage and markings and states
precisely the state of these aircraft found at Cape Gloucester, New
Britain Island.
-
- "13.
The (Japanese) Army Air Service normally uses a lighter green paint (than
the Naval Air Service) with the under surfaces remaining unpainted. Much
effort has been expended in some instances, notably on LILY, NICK and
Dinah, to fill any metal overlaps with putty to achieve a very smooth
surface.
-
- 14.
Most recent Army camouflage has been very light daubs of green over the
naked skin or over light grey paint, giving a silver grey-green mottled
effect, but the under surfaces remain unpainted.
-
- 15.
Other than Type 100 2ER DINAH, which is normally painted grey, Japanese
Army airplanes are predominately green. Exceptions have been the discovery
of two TYPE 1 F OSCARs at Cape Gloucester which were painted BLUE (N.B.
author's emphasis!) with unpainted under surfaces. Other exceptions have
been a very few airplanes found to be painted brown."
-
- Editors
note: Picture at http://www.j-aircraft.com/jiml/ki-43_1f_capegloucester.jpg
-
- A
US Signal Corps photograph of one of the Cape Gloucester Oscars (above)
appears to show a lighter finish. This is one of a series of photographs
which were taken on Cape Gloucester Airfield after it was captured by US
Marines on 26 December 1943. It is not possible to discriminate the color
of the upper surfaces in this view, however, the tail markings clearly
reveal that this Nakajima Ki-43 I Oscar was assigned to No. 1 Hiko Sentai.
-
- Jeff
ETHELL has published many color photographs of aircraft taken during WW II
by veterans and there are rumors of a color film taken at Cape Gloucester
by USMC combat photographers. Perhaps we will yet see the aircraft
captured at Cape Gloucester in "living color" as well!(;>)
-
- Larry
HICKEY added the following comment to his contribution of information
related to the "blue" Oscar research.
-
- "Re:
The two 'blue' Ki 43 Is found at Cape Gloucester. Three Type Is were found
there; s/n 776, estimated to have been built in late 11/42 with date
evaluated unservicable (U/S) as Sept. 1, 1943; s/n 804, built Dec. 1942,
and estimated U/S Aug. 27, 1943; and s/n 808, built Dec. 1942, and
estimated U/S May 30, 1943. If the intelligence document is correct, two
of these have to be painted blue on the top surfaces!"
-
- Credit:
Material research by Lawrence J. Hickey and IRPC, Boulder, Colorado; Art
(c) Minoru Akimoto, Aireview Magazine No.193, 6/65, p.109; Photo, USSC/NARA
via LRA
-
- Re:
The "Blue" Cape Gloucester Oscars!
-
- Posted
By: Rob Graham - the ReiShikiSenGuy
- Date:
Friday, 16 August 2002, at 4:02 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: The "Blue" Cape Gloucester Oscars! *PIC* (James F.
Lansdale)
-
- Excellent
presentation!
-
- However,
we must remember - as you point out - that photographs can't be always
considered a good source for color. An old yellowed negative can give us a
bluish tint to an aircraft when the negative is printed.
-
-
- Posted
By: richard dunn <rdunn@rhsmith.umd.edu>
- Date:
Friday, 16 August 2002, at 5:25 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: The "Blue" Cape Gloucester Oscars! *PIC* (James F.
Lansdale)
-
- The
actual crash info on these three a/c show each was painted a different
color only one probably something like standard.
-
- No.
776 "Light blue upper. Unpainted, lower."
-
- No.
804 "Light green upper portion of fuselage, unpainted lower portion
of fuselage. Top side wings light green, lower side unpinted."
-
- No.
808 "Dark green, upper. Unpainted, lower.:
-
- No.
776 had a red rudder and red elevators. No other unit or patriotic
markings mentioned. Others had no markings that were reported (each has a
"none" entered after "Tail:" and
"Patriotic;" in the markings section).
-
- As
mentioned in my Ki 43-I armament article (I've suspected nobody has read
it!) 776 and 804 had only 2x7.7mm and this was undoubtedly non-standard
leading me to speculate these were special purpose a/c in use after their
normal combat roles in regular units. No. 808 was so demolished its
armament could not be determined. No. 776 was said to be in "fair
shape". Possibly the a/c in the photo?
-
- I
believe there was also a blue Oscar found at Alexishafen but I have no
detailed crash report on this just a brief mention in an intelligence
summary.
-
- Keep
up the good work. Love to get to the bottom of this one.
-
- Re:
Light "Blue" Oscars! *PIC*
-
- Posted
By: James F. Lansdale <LRAJIM@aol.com>
- Date:
Friday, 16 August 2002, at 7:19 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: Light "Blue" Cscars! (richard dunn)
-
- Thank
you Rick for the follow-up on the colors of the Cape Gloucester Oscars.
-
- I
am hopeful a veteran's souvenir with paint or a color photo will turn-up
one day.
-
- Armed
with your information I will return to NARA and look more thoroughly
through the "JAM Tins" or "Tinnies" (JA Makers Plates
and Markings cards with data plates and/or serial numbers cut from
aircraft still attached). I am sure the Cape Gloucester Oscars, s/nos 776,
804, and 808, were gone over by some AATIU.
-
- From
your description, the Oscar in the photo below may well be s/n 776.
-
- Again,
thank you for your vital contributions.
-
- Editors
note: Picture at http://www.j-aircraft.com/jiml/ki-43_1f_capegloucester.jpg
-
- Ki-43-I
undersurface colour again!
-
- Posted
By: Andrew Johnson <ajo@ceh.ac.uk>
- Date:
Thursday, 8 August 2002, at 10:20 a.m.
-
- Please
could someone reassure me on the undersurface colour of Ki-43-I used by
64th Sentai during 1942? The Hasewgawa 64th Sentai Ki-43 they have as
Grey-green, whilst they recommend nmf for their 1st Sentai marked version.
-
- Sorry
to be so dumb, I'm sure we've discussed this before!
-
- Re:
Ki-43-I undersurface colour again!
-
- Posted
By: Don Marsh <marsh44@fuse.net>
- Date:
Thursday, 8 August 2002, at 2:16 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Ki-43-I undersurface colour again! (Andrew Johnson)
-
- I'd
opt for NMF underside.
-
- Re:
Ki-43-I undersurface colour again! *PIC*
-
- Posted
By: Hiroyuki Takeuchi
- Date:
Friday, 9 August 2002, at 9:42 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Ki-43-I undersurface colour again! (Don Marsh)
-
- IMHO
some had painted undersufaces and some had NMF undersurfaces. It is
difficult to judge from photos, but some just seem like they are painted
while others look NMF.
-
- Editors
note: Picture at http://homepage2.nifty.com/02366/mokei/research/64thsentaiki43.jpg
-
- Re:
Ki-43-I undersurface colour again!
-
- Posted
By: Andrew Johnson <andrew.johnson28@ntlworld.com>
- Date:
Sunday, 11 August 2002, at 1:41 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Ki-43-I undersurface colour again! *PIC* (Hiroyuki
Takeuchi)
-
- Thankyou
for your pictures Hiroyuki! As for as there is a rule for the Ki-43-I I'm
going for the 64th Sentai being unique with JAAF grey-green undersurface,
and the others (1st and 50th Sentai) being nmf.
-
- I
hope no one comes up with any contradictory evidence for the 64th Sentai
Ki-43 in 1942 as I've just painted mine!
-
- Re:
Ki-43-I undersurface colour again!
-
- Posted
By: jackson <j.fincher@attbi.com>
- Date:
Sunday, 11 August 2002, at 2:06 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Ki-43-I undersurface colour again! (Andrew Johnson)
-
- I
kneel at the fountain of knowlege again...I'm finally digging into my 1/32
Hasegawa Oscar. It's an earlier kit with Japanese instructions so the
color call-outs need some clarification.
-
- Can
any of my esteemed panel of JAAF experts fill in the blanks for me?
- 1.
Interior color and rear deck (under the canopy color)
- 2.
What color should I paint my photo etch lap belts?
- 3.
What color are the wheel wells and interior of the covers?
- 4.
After seeing that fabulous NMF finish I'm just inspired!What color is
appropriate for the anti-glare shield? My Aircam seem to favor a dark blue
over the cowl and behind the rear deck.
-
- 5.
What colors are appropriate for the fabric control surfaces for NMF A/C?
-
- Re:
Ki-43-I undersurface colour again!
-
- Posted
By: Ken Glass <ken.glass@eudoramail.com>
- Date:
Sunday, 11 August 2002, at 6:21 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Ki-43-I undersurface colour again! (jackson)
-
- I
am no expert but I try to keep up with the info that has come out on this
website and elsewhere in the last few years. Some of the stuff below is
from Mikish's various publications and the Asahi Journal. I can't cite
chapter and verse where to find it if challenged to do so. Here are my
suggestions to your itemized questions. Many of these were used on my
1/48th scale Nichimo Ki.43 I kit build.
-
- #1a
A dark blue-gray near FS 36118 for the decking under the canopy.
-
- #1b
A glossy transluscent green or blue on the cockpit side walls. Seen on New
Zealand Ki.43 I restoration.
-
- #1c
A gray-green near FS 14255 for the equipment boxes and other add-on pieces
in the cockpit. Mikish ref.
-
- #1d
black gun butts and faces of instrument panels.
-
- #2
You can't beat the Eduard prepainted IJA/IJN seat belts. I am not sure if
these have been done in 1/32nd scale yet. Even the stitching shows against
the webbing on the 1/48th scale set I recently picked up.
-
- #3
See #1b above for the wheel wells and covers.
-
- #4
I used straight black on my Nichimo Ki.43 I. I have heard about the
blue-black relics now in the hands of the collectors. I wonder if the
paint appeared noticibly blue-black when freshly applied.
-
- #5
Nakajima is said to have had a medium gray dope for fabric surfaces.
Opinion varies as to whether the fabric surfaces were: left in this gray
color, over painted in a silver dope or in the light gray-green. The best
estimate I can give you for the gray dope color is FS 34226 or Munsell 5GY
5/1. Mitsubishi's variant of the light gray-green overall camo color has
been cited as Munsell 7.8Y 5.5/2.5. Go to Wal*Mart's paint section with
the 'ColorPlace' brand paint swatches and look for card number 627 and the
color 'River Bank' number 96273 for a near match. The Munsell chip is just
a tinge greener than the Wal*Mart paint chip. Asahi Journal sold some
specially made up Munsell color chips matched to samples of the fabric
gray dope color and the Mitsubishi variant of the overall gray-green
color.
-
- My
Nichimo Ki.43 I was finished in a FS 14255 sidewalls interior instead of
the #1b. And, as an after thought, I used Model Master buffing aluminum
metalizer on the undersides of my 1st Sentai Ki.43 I with the
orange-yellow rudder and elevators.
-
-
- Posted
By: Nick Millman
- Date:
Saturday, 10 August 2002, at 12:14 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Ki-43-I undersurface colour again! *PIC* (Hiroyuki
Takeuchi)
-
- A
fine deduction and well presented! According to my own sources 64th Sentai
had some aircraft which were delivered in overall grey-green finish and
(presumably) camouflaged at unit level.
-
- Both
Japanese and Allied primary sources make it apparent that there was
considerable variation to be seen in the colours of early Hayabusas. This
perfectly accords with the movements and adventures of units and aircraft.
However, having said that, NMF does not always appear "shiny".
Heavily oxidised and stained NMF may appear a pale flat grey or even close
to a dirty white - and coincidentally both colour descriptions for the
undersurfaces of Oscar feature in RAF combat reports of the period.
-
- But
let's not fall into the time trap of a "standard NMF undersurface for
JAAF aircraft" and add yet another tidy but mythical one-liner to the
dogma surrounding this subject! One of my profiles depicts a very
different looking 64th Sentai Ki-43 - but my well-founded if radical
speculation seems to have been censored! Some of the 64th's Hayabusa may
even have had their bellies painted in a beautiful azure blue - courtesy
of the RAF!
-
- Re:
Ki-43-I undersurface colour again!
-
- Posted
By: Don Marsh <marsh44@fuse.net>
- Date:
Friday, 9 August 2002, at 10:10 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Ki-43-I undersurface colour again! *PIC* (Hiroyuki
Takeuchi)
-
- I
agree completely. I've always thought that, from the existing photos, some
are painted and some NMF. I wondered after my posting if perhaps I
shouldn't have mentioned this, but decided to keep it simple. While some
appear to have painted lower surfaces, most are obviously NMF. Some appear
to have been NMF overall and to have had topside painting added later in
the field with the undersides left NMF. Also, since it was common practice
for the JAAF to leave the bellies natural... I didn't go back to expand on
my comment. Thank you for filling out the rest of the picture so
eloquently.
-
- Re:
Ki-43-I undersurface colour again!
-
- Posted
By: James F. Lansdale <LRAJIM@aol.com>
- Date:
Saturday, 10 August 2002, at 5:19 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Ki-43-I undersurface colour again! *PIC* (Hiroyuki
Takeuchi)
-
- I
agree that photographic analysis may be used to distinguish the difference
between some NMF aircraft schemes from some of the lighter-painted
finishes. I have not detected a pattern, but the majority of Oscars
produced by Nakajima, in photographs, do appear NMF. Others, identified as
having been produced by Tachikawa, appear to have been painted a light
color on the lower surfaces.
-
- A
few years ago, I examined the wreckage from several Oscars outside the
Champlin Fighter Museum in Arizona. I do not know the model of Ki-43 nor
the manufacturer, however, an analysis of these airframes, did reveal the
remains of paint which closely matched FS-36350.
-
- These
remains were pulled out of Russia (Kurile Is. ?) and sold for restoration!
I have one or two small color samples, but, again, I haven't a clue as to
any specific model of the Ki-43; serial numbers; nor manufacturer.
-
- I
would appreciate any information on these hulks provided by our members
which might give us some more evidence with which to connect this color
application with a manufacturer or serial number run.
-
- Re:
Ki-43-I undersurface colour again!
-
- Posted
By: Bill Sanborn <bsanborn@psemc.com>
- Date:
Sunday, 11 August 2002, at 8:01 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Ki-43-I undersurface colour again! (James F. Lansdale)
-
- The
planes are as of two years ago located at the Texas Airplane Factory out
side of Fort Worth. I got to see them when I was at Nats in Dallas. If
memory serves, they were Ki-43IIs. I did not see S/Ns for the planes, but
this sound like a road trip for Rob or Greg.
-
- Re:
Camo Scheme for Ki-43-II's by Tachikawa? *PIC*
-
- Posted
By: James F. Lansdale <LRAJIM@aol.com>
- Date:
Monday, 12 August 2002, at 7:07 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Ki-43-I undersurface colour again! (Bill Sanborn)
-
- These
hulks may be Tachikawa-constructed versions (at least, if they are Ki-43
II's). They would have had the Tachikawa camouflage scheme which, IIRC,
was dark green upper over "gray" or "gray-green" lower
surfaces (not NMF).
-
- See
below for a scan of a Tachikawa constructed Ki-43 II s/n 7475.
-
- Editors
note: Picture at http://www.j-aircraft.com/jiml/ki-43_7475.jpg
-
- Re:
Looks like a Ki-43 III Ko to me!!!
-
- Posted
By: James F. Lansdale <LRAJIM@aol.com>
- Date:
Tuesday, 13 August 2002, at 5:51 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: Looks like a Ki-43 III Ko to me!!! *No Text* (Nick Millman)
-
- Thou
art correct! (:>)
-
- Am
I correct that this particular bird was built by Tachikawa?
-
- Jim
LONG, can you check s/n 7475 for manufacturer please?
-
- Re:
Looks like a Ki-43 III Ko to me!!!
-
- Posted
By: Jim Long <jimilong@msn.com>
- Date:
Tuesday, 13 August 2002, at 10:12 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Looks like a Ki-43 III Ko to me!!! (James F. Lansdale)
-
- The
serial number 7475 can't be used alone to identify a manufacturer. The
range of serial numbers for Nakajima-built Ki-43-IIs went up to 7487 from
5001, and the range of numbers for Tachikawa-built Ki-43-IIIs went up to
8727 from 7001. Therefore there was a Ki-43 by each maker with that same
serial number: 7475. So some other identification characteristic must be
used. I believe that in this case the feature would be the individual
rocket-type exhaust stacks on the engine. That would suggest that 7475 was
a Ki-43-III built by Tachikawa.
-
- Re:
Looks like a Ki-43 III Ko to me!!!
-
- Posted
By: Nick Millman
- Date:
Tuesday, 13 August 2002, at 3:35 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Looks like a Ki-43 III Ko to me!!! (James F. Lansdale)
-
- Tachikawa
built 1,727 Ki-43 III by all accounts (serials 7001-8727) - more than I
realised or would have believed!
-
- To
follow the earlier thread about the relics, 54th Sentai are reported to
have used only Ki-43 II (but who knows?) - but some of their examples had
an interesting "veined" camouflage with well-defined blotches
like the Ki-45. There are strong suggestions, and some compelling
evidence, that Oscar sometimes dressed for battle in green mottle over a
grey-green (hairyokushoku?) overall base coat as well as the more familiar
green mottle over NMF. Perhaps it all depended on the exigencies of the
supply and demand situation at the Field Depots - the "proper"
finishing standard versus the expedient, "get them to the front
quickly" timescale driven by the ebb and flow of war.
-
- Re:
Looks like a Ki-43 III Ko to me!!!
-
- Posted
By: Hiroyuki Takeuchi
- Date:
Tuesday, 13 August 2002, at 9:36 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Looks like a Ki-43 III Ko to me!!! (James F. Lansdale)
-
- Ki43III
production was undertaken by Tachikawa to let Nakajima concentrate on Ki84
production. S/n 7001 and beyond are all Tachikawa made.
-
- Re:
Looks like a Ki-43 III Ko to me!!!
-
- Posted
By: Ryan Boerema <ryann1k2j@aol.com>
- Date:
Tuesday, 13 August 2002, at 10:51 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Looks like a Ki-43 III Ko to me!!! (Hiroyuki Takeuchi)
-
- Did
Tachikawa do away then with the anti-glare panel, since the entire topside
was painted? I don't think I've ever seen a -III with one.
-
-
- Posted
By: Andy <Hahn-Dreieich@t-online.de>
- Date:
Tuesday, 30 July 2002, at 6:45 a.m.
-
- I´m
searching for Ki-43I in natural metal finish.
- Most
photographs show "1028" of a Training unit.
- Does
anybody has some hints if there are any
- other
references?
-
- Re:
Natural Metal Ki-43I
-
- Posted
By: William Knoth <baronred4@cs.com>
- Date:
Tuesday, 30 July 2002, at 8:51 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Natural Metal Ki-43I (Andy)
-
- There's
one in koku-fan Illustrated No.79 has one and in No.80 there's one in
manchuku makings
-
- Re:
Natural Metal Ki-43I
-
- Posted
By: Don Marsh <marsh44@fuse.net>
- Date:
Friday, 2 August 2002, at 4:32 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Natural Metal Ki-43I (Andy)
-
- The
first dozen or so Ki-43 protoype/experimental a/c were natural. They were
very similar in appearance to the production Model I. Also, many schools
operated natural finished Oscar 1s & 2s: Akeno, Kumagaya, Tokorozawa
and Hokota to name a few. Most of the school photos show Model 2s, but
there are many Akeno photos of Model 1s. And it's a safe bet that most, if
not nearly all, of the schools operated Model 1s at some time.
-
- Re:
Natural Metal Ki-43I
-
- Posted
By: Nick Millman
- Date:
Saturday, 3 August 2002, at 3:12 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Natural Metal Ki-43I (Andy)
-
- When
the 59th Sentai converted to the Ki-43 I in 1941 their first aircraft were
in natural metal. They are alleged to have worn a large lightning flash in
the Chutai colour on each side of the fuselage, together with the white
so-called "combat stripe". Although I am personally sceptical
that the Ki-43 I ever had this flash (the Ki-27 certainly did) it makes
for a very striking scheme indeed. Towards the end of 1941, before the
outbreak of hostilities their natural metal Ki-43 I sported the later unit
marking of a diagonal tail band and span-wise bands on the tailplanes in
the Chutai colours - also very striking.
-
- The
first Ki-43 I aircraft of the 24th Sentai were also in natural metal
finish.
-
- The
64th Sentai briefly operated natural metal Ki-43 I before leaving Japan in
preparation for the Pacific War.
-
- Good
references are Model Art 395 (if you can find it), FAOW 13 and 65.
"Pod Lupa" 11 (ACE Publications) and AJ Press Monografie
Lotnicze 48 are also worth looking out for. The British modelling magazine
Scale Aviation Modeller ran a feature on the Ki-43 in their September 2000
issue. Twelve very beautiful colour profiles and a page crammed full of
colourful tail markings by Richard J Caruana - but use with caution!
-
- Re:
Natural Metal Ki-43I *PIC*
-
- Posted
By: Hiroyuki Takeuchi
- Date:
Friday, 9 August 2002, at 9:57 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Natural Metal Ki-43I (Nick Millman)
-
- According
to MA395, the 59th actually wore the big flash when it first received the
Ki43 in June 1941, but this was abolished in favor of a small flash on the
tail in August (top profile page 105) which was changed again in October
to the diagonal line on the fin when they went back to Tachikawa for
airframe modifications. Assuming there are records or witnesses to back
this up, the big flash were worn, for a short time.
-
- Here's
a nice shot of a NMF 64th sentai Ki43, also from Model Art 395.
-
- Editors
note: Picture at http://homepage2.nifty.com/02366/mokei/research/64thnmf.jpg
-
- Re:
Natural Metal Ki-43I
-
- Posted
By: Nick Millman
- Date:
Saturday, 10 August 2002, at 12:32 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Natural Metal Ki-43I *PIC* (Hiroyuki Takeuchi)
-
- I'll
keep an open mind but it would be nice to see some photographic evidence
to support Model Arts chronology. I think the depiction of the small tail
flash is a misinterpretation of the change of marking from early sources.
If all these changes really occurred in the time frame suggested then the
ground crew were kept busy on a messy, time-consuming but relatively
unimportant task when there must be have been more pressing urgencies!
-
- FAOW
65 has photographs of a camouflaged 59th Sentai Ki-43 I with the full
panoply of tail stripes (page 75) and photographs of what appear to be NMF
aircraft of the 64th Sentai (page 23).
-
- The
pic you posted is interesting as it shows a coloured edge to both the
so-called "combat stripe" and 3rd Chutai orange-yellow tail
arrow. But is this aircraft NMF or overall grey-green? Could this be one
of the first 11 pre-production aircraft finished in overall hairyokushoku?
-
- Re:
Natural Metal Ki-43I
-
- Posted
By: Hiroyuki Takeuchi
- Date:
Saturday, 10 August 2002, at 7:51 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Natural Metal Ki-43I (Nick Millman)
-
- Don't
know about the gray. The rivets on the fin give the impression of NMF but
the airframe does look rather uniform in tone.
-
- Re:
Natural Metal Ki-43I *PIC*
-
- Posted
By: Hiroyuki Takeuchi
- Date:
Friday, 9 August 2002, at 10:02 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Natural Metal Ki-43I *PIC* (Hiroyuki Takeuchi)
-
- BTW
I did a NMF 59th sentai ki43 years ago. The rudder marking is not backed
by evidence but MA395 shows illustrations of the pilot's initial worn on
the rudder on later aircrafts of the same unit.
-
- Editors
note: Picture at http://homepage2.nifty.com/02366/mokei/ncmki43.JPG
-
- Beautiful!
What kit/scale? *No Text*
-
- Posted
By: Nick Millman
- Date:
Saturday, 10 August 2002, at 12:17 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: Natural Metal Ki-43I *PIC* (Hiroyuki Takeuchi)
-
- Re:
Beautiful! What kit/scale?
-
- Posted
By: Hiroyuki Takeuchi
- Date:
Saturday, 10 August 2002, at 7:48 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: Beautiful! What kit/scale? *No Text* (Nick Millman)
-
- Thanks
it's the 1/48 Nichimo kit.
-
- And
it makes sense about all the marking changes being irrational, but we all
know how bureaucracy (like peacetime military) can be pretty crazy so I
won't rule it out on terms of whether or not it sounds rational.
-
- I
too, would wish to have photographic evidence but while photographic
evidence will prove it existed, the lack of it would not disprove it
either.
-
- As
a modeller, I am inclined to build models in "unproven" markings
since even it it is later proven to be wrong, it is ot the end of the
world; it's just a plastic model. I'd make reservations about non first
hand information if I was writing historical articles.
-
-
- Posted
By: Rob Asbury <easbury@sc.rr.com>
- Date:
Monday, 29 July 2002, at 6:45 p.m.
-
- I'm
working on the engine of the new Hasegawa early Oscar and am stumped over
the color of the crankcase and pushrods. The Hasegawa instructions say
silver for both. The Aero Detail pictures of a restored engine show a
neutral gray crankcase with black pushrods. I'm inclined to believe the
latter. Anyone know for sure?
-
- Re:
Ki-43-I Engine Colors?
-
- Posted
By: Mike Goodwin <Mike.Goodwin@bigfoot.com>
- Date:
Tuesday, 30 July 2002, at 2:07 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: Ki-43-I Engine Colors? (Rob Asbury)
-
- Most
Nakajima engine factory photos show shiny black pushrods with either bare
metal or gloss neutral grey crankcases. The grey might be Navy-specific,
but it is difficult to differentiate in b/w photos.
-
-
- Posted
By: Jeff <chipdog@fuse.net>
- Date:
Saturday, 20 July 2002, at 5:31 p.m.
-
- Having
recently obtained this, is there an "easy" way to fix the
cockpit? The floor sits way too low and the seats look slightly oversized.
Was ther ever an update made for this kit? Over than that the kit appears
ok.
-
- Re:
Nichimo Oscar
-
- Posted
By: jackson <FincherI@aol.com>
- Date:
Saturday, 20 July 2002, at 6:55 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Nichimo Oscar (Jeff)
-
- Love
the kit, had the same problems with the ccockpit. I used the kit seat but
trimmed the bottom of the bulkheads to get the cockpit to sit where it
looked right. I'm not aware of any resin cockpit for the kit but I don't
know of any that would have the amount of detail that I thought was
amazing for a kit of the era,
-
- Re:
Nichimo Oscar
-
- Posted
By: John MacGregor <JohnMacG6@hotmail.com>
- Date:
Sunday, 21 July 2002, at 7:55 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: Nichimo Oscar (Jeff)
-
- Jeff,
another point to watch - in fact about the ONLY assembly problem in the
kit - is that the air intake on the bottom of the cowling is a rather poor
fit. It needs some subtle sanding and trimming to fit properly.
- Otherwise
it's a pretty good kit - especially when you consider its' age!
-
-
- Posted
By: Andrew Johnson <andrew.johnson28@ntlworld.com>
- Date:
Thursday, 18 July 2002, at 1:27 p.m.
-
- Can
anyone helped with the following questions?
-
- The
new Hasegawa Ki-43 I has a white arrow with blue edging as the colour for
the Sentai hombu (headquarters flight). The Hikoki book by Peter Scott on
JAAF markings has the Sentai hombu as blue with white markings. Which is
correct for early 1942?
-
- If
I wanted to depict another Sentai hombu aircraft other than Tateo Kato
could I do this simply using the Sentai hombu arrow and white theatre
stripe around the rear fuselage?
-
- Re:
64th sentai hombu in 1942 question
-
- Posted
By: Nick Millman
- Date:
Sunday, 21 July 2002, at 3:05 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: 64th sentai hombu in 1942 question (Andrew Johnson)
-
- The
Hikoki book is not correct. Sentai Commander Kato's Hayabusa, no.318, had
a white arrow thinly edged with cobalt blue and a horizontal white
fuselage command band to distinguish him from the Chutai commanders, who
used a diagonal command band. This is confirmed by photographic evidence.
The position and style of the white wing bands are less clear.
-
- Blue
was the colour usually adopted for the Sentai Hombu markings. However it
was felt that colour did not provide sufficient identification against the
dark green uppersurfaces paint of the Hayabusa and the 1st Chutai white
was adopted instead. In the 1st Chutai the white arrow was thinly edged in
red but later a plain white arrow was used.
-
- As
far as I know no other Sentai Hombu aircraft have been identified as such.
I may be able to post more information about this once I have dug out and
reviewed my notes, which include letters from former 64th Sentai
personnel.
-
- Some
of the early Hayabusa issued to this unit were overall grey-green (hairyokushoku)
and had dark green paint applied to their uppersurfaces only.
-
- Re:
64th sentai hombu in 1942 question
-
- Posted
By: Andrew Johnson <andrew.johnson28@ntlworld.com>
- Date:
Tuesday, 23 July 2002, at 1:32 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: 64th sentai hombu in 1942 question (Nick Millman)
-
- Thanks
for your response, I don't know your e-mail!
-
- I
know the Luftwaffe had a Stabschwarm with an adjutant, technical officer
etc, was a Sentai Hombu basically the same, ie about 4 aircraft?
-
- Re:
64th sentai hombu in 1942 question
-
- Posted
By: Nick Millman
- Date:
Tuesday, 23 July 2002, at 2:12 p.m.
-
- In
Response To: Re: 64th sentai hombu in 1942 question (Andrew Johnson)
-
- yes,
but it was a looser arrangement in the JAAF and sometimes the Sentai
commander flew with Chutai wingmen.
-
- I
still haven't dug out my notes but I recall I do have something about this
as it relates to the 64th Sentai. I'm pretty sure no other Sentai Hombu
aircraft have been identified but I have something recorded about Kato's
wingmen.
-
-
- Posted
By: Joe Brown <bulmer69@shaw.ca>
- Date:
Wednesday, 3 July 2002, at 1:32 a.m.
-
- I
just acquired the Nichimo 1/48 Ki 43-1 kit. I'm looking for info on the
tiger stripe scheme on the decal sheet. Its in japanese and only shows the
profile. Are there any plan views of this scheme? Whose air force insignia
is a white elephant on a red rectangle
-
- Re:
Ki 43 info needed
-
- Posted
By: Hiroyuki Takeuchi
- Date:
Wednesday, 3 July 2002, at 4:47 a.m.
-
- In
Response To: Ki 43 info needed (Joe Brown)
-
- The
tiger stripe scheme is, like George states, is for the Thai AF. However,
the Thai AF did not fly the Ki-43I. They flew the Ki43-II. So save the
elephant decals for a "II" kit.